Top College News Subscribe to the Newsletter

Dog training students should give more warning before class

Published: Monday, September 10, 2012

Updated: Monday, September 10, 2012 21:09

 

When I walk into a classroom, it is hard enough to focus on the lecture at hand without having to worry about seeing something that terrifies me and breaks my concentration. Having service dogs in a classroom with me is my biggest fear: being trapped in a room with an unknown animal.

Do not get me wrong, I respect the people training the dogs. As a person with a disability, and having had friends with visual impairments, I know just how helpful they can be and how much joy people with such impairments get from having a trained dog in their lives.

But when you have a fear of canines the way I do, it doesn’t really matter what they are being used for; you just want to get away from them as quickly as possible. It would be easy for me to fall if a dog jumps up on me because of my slight disability. I try to distance myself from the dogs as much as I possibly can when I encounter one. I even cut across the Green at night if need be. 

The dog that’s being trained could be the nicest, sweetest dog around, but having had bad experiences with other dogs that have tackled me to the ground, I treat every dog I come across with suspicion. I feel that there are also some dogs out there that even though their trainer thinks is well-behaved and very friendly, will still snap at me or break loose from its leash and tackle me.

But it is not just fear that motivates me to bring this topic up; it’s also allergies that make this point one near and dear to my heart. Though I do not have allergies to dog fur, my sister has severe allergies to most domestic animals. If a dog even licks her, she breaks out in a rash almost immediately. I am concerned about people with allergies, even if they are not as severe as my sister’s. Pet dander, even if it is slight, can cause those who are allergic serious problems: they sneeze and cough, and their eyes water. It’s really hard to focus in some classes with the smell of mold, mildew and certain scents, but it is incredibly hard to focus when you add dog hair into the equation. 

According to the Allergy and Asthma Foundation of America, 15 to 30 percent of people who have allergies have allergic reactions to cats and dogs. I would have to imagine many students here at the university have this issue, and there are probably five or six students in a class that have this issue. 

Allergies and fear are only two reasons I bring this issue to attention. It is also a question of personal space. Even the most obedient and well-trained dog will want to explore its surroundings; it is a fact of nature. But does this really mean that dogs should be allowed to sniff around students’ possession and invade our space bubbles when we are all in classrooms? I should say I do not think so.

There was one day in my British literature class early last semester when another student brought her service dog and sat behind me. The dog started to sniff at my belongings, and I looked at her and asked her if she wouldn’t mind controlling her dog. She complied, but before class even began, the dog started doing it again. She looked down at the dog but did not do anything about it. I would have liked to have said to her, “There is no bomb in my bag, and the reason my coat smells funky is because I leant it to a friend who went clubbing last night.” But I didn’t, I just got up and moved to the front of the class. I think she got the message; she and her dog never came back to class again.

Now I am not saying we should ban all service dogs in training from classrooms. What I am saying is please be courteous to others. If you are going to introduce a dog into the classroom, please ask all the students in the class if they will have issues with the dog being there. Most issues can be solved with seating arrangements, but it is still courteous to be asked if there are any issues. 

There’s no doubt that I respect what these students are doing. It is an honorable thing to give your time to train a service dog for the disabled or visually impaired. But it is also an honorable thing to ensure every person in your classroom feels comfortable with it.

Recommended: Articles that may interest you

9 comments

Anonymous
Sat Oct 13 2012 21:14
Wow.
Talk about the tyranny of the minority and the self entitled bullying that goes with it.
What nonsense.
They are dogs, not people.
Unless it's a guide dog, they don't belong in classes.
Nor do dogs belong in restaurants, shops,air-plane cabins,buses or playgrounds.
Anonymous
Fri Sep 21 2012 05:46
I feel the same way as the author when I'm in a restaurant trying to eat.
Anonymous
Thu Sep 13 2012 16:44
As a student raising a dog on campus, I want to clear up some of the misconceptions. The dogs that we are raising are service dogs in training. They are by no means actual service dogs, nor do their raisers have disabilities. However, the University supports these organizations and we do have permission to bring the dogs into any University building, this includes taking them to classes with us. This permission from the university is all that we technically need, but we do go a step farther to try and accommodate everyone. It is a requirement for the raisers to email each professor they have for classes every semester, and ask for that professors specific approval to bring the dog into that classroom. Some professors say yes right away, some say no right away, and some email the entire class to see if anyone has a problem with the dog. It is the professors discretion as to if they wish to contact each student in the class. This is where it falls on anyone in the class who may have an allergy or fear. If you have an issue with the dog being in the class, kindly explain this to the professor (who will talk to the raiser) or talk to the raiser directly. Every person raising a dog on campus will be understanding and accommodating. We do take into account other students fears or allergies because we know our dogs are not trained service dogs. I have had situations like this happen often, and I have gone completely out of my way to be sure not to frighten anyone. If we notice someone with a fear, we remove ourselves from the situation. If you have a problem with a dog in the classroom, you have to speak up and let the raiser know about the fear. They will most likely not bring the dog to that class, or will make a serious effort to not come into contact with you. However we cannot try to accommodate you if we do not know who you are.
While it's great that you are able to express your opinion on here, if you ever encounter an actual service dog aiding someone with a disability, no matter where you are, the disabled person does not have to ask for specific permission everywhere they go. They already have it.
Anonymous
Thu Sep 13 2012 12:49
I am appalled. Are you serious?

"But does this really mean that dogs should be allowed to sniff around students' possession and invade our space bubbles when we are all in classrooms?"
Ok it's a DOG. Let it be, they don't have to stand there and be complete statues just because you can't handle it being there. What do you care what it sniffs? You think its going to go around and tell everyone whats in there or something? There's a difference between invading personal space and creating a problem where is is none.

"The dog started to sniff at my belongings, and I looked at her and asked her if she wouldn't mind controlling her dog."
Wow there's a way to communicate this without being so rude. Try "I'm not very good with dogs, would you mind sitting farther from me?" I know multiple trainers and this kind of request would not be a problem at all.

I think you need to get some help with your fear instead of making the world bow down to you.

SD Handler Person
Wed Sep 12 2012 19:05
For non-disabled students who are puppy raisers, it would be good to check first that there are no other students in the class who have bad allergies (such as breathing issues, not a rash from being licked since that is completely preventable) or severe fear (such as can't be in the same room, not will be happy a seat apart since that is a resolution). For disabled students with service dogs, the school cannot do such a check for privacy reasons, so you'll need to wait for classes to begin. Unless your allergies or fears reach the level of being disabling, you are the one who needs to move seats/change classes/take meds/etc. If your allergies/fears disable you, both parties must be accommodated, which means things like sitting on opposite sides of the room or changing/dropping courses without penalty or fees/withheld deposits. Disabled students have every right to sit in classes just as everyone else does and that right doesn't change just because they use a certain medical device such as a service dog, wheelchair, or oxygen. Also, real, fully-trained service dogs don't sniff through others' bags, lick others, etc. so you only need to worry about the in-training puppies.

Marine: That is NOT why separation of church and state exists. It exists so that the government cannot run the church, which is how it was in England and what the Pilgrims came here to get away from.

AllergiesFearYaSoWhat
Wed Sep 12 2012 10:29
Well as someone who has family members who are allergic to dogs and cats plus who are scared of dogs I can understand the wish to not be around them if at all possible, but guess what? Their rights trump yours - as in they have every right to have the service animal with them because they have every right and freedom that you are entitled to and are making use of that right with the aid of the animal. I'm allergic to a world of a lot of things yet I would NOT force anyone around me to cater to my needs because they are MY Needs not theres, just as my son understands that he can be as scared of dogs as he is but that he shares this earth with them thus he has to suck it up from time to time and do what he needs to do (yes even if that means walking on the other wise of the side walk or changing seats in class). I would do a lot of things to make this place safe for my family but since I can only control to a limited degree the main enviroment that they live in (our home) they are taught to take care of themselves and not expect society of a whole to bend to their will/wishes/needs outside of reason and asking another human to not bring their aid into the environment they happen to share with another falls into that category of something you can not expect to be catered to.

If you are so scared then there are many options out there that with time and for many help in that area, believe it or not desensitizing treatment does work for many people so that is something the author might wish to look into. Allergies ya there is treatment for them as well though not everyone has the same rate of success with the treatment (or can even take the treatment for that matter) but its an option.

Marine saved by his Service Dog
Wed Sep 12 2012 07:56
As a disabled vet with a service dog I have to say that I respect the authors individual rights. Something that makes this country great is the ability for all it's citizens to be respected. I am bothered when I see people saying that "I deserve" at the expense of others. I and all my fellow veterans didn't sacrifice for only a portion of our citizens, we did it for everyone and just as those like me "deserve" to have our service dogs with us everywhere, others with their own issues, if its the dogs, are just as "deserving" to be free of them. It's like religion. We are, in this country, free to follow our chosen faith - not just those others that the bigger faiths approve of. That is the entire reason behind the separation of church and state. So when you think that your faith should be the basis for any form of legislation just imagine how you'd feel if it was someone else's faith that was the basis. This is what the founding fathers intended to protect against. Now while I feel that a dog phobia is a condition that with time, patience and the proper education of dogs coupled with some good experiences with canines under adequate supervision leading to a resolution - I also believe that someone with this fear should be entitled to request a different class without having to sit with dogs. I respect the author and their issues just as I'd hope they respect mine. We should all remember the Golden Rule - Do unto others....... When did this become a thing of the past?
Anonymous
Tue Sep 11 2012 14:38
YOU are the one with a personal issue involving dogs; it's your responsibility to make accommodations for yourself, not the other way around. Service dogs have every much a right to be in the classroom as you do, and if you have a personal issue with it, it's your responsibility to bring it up with the owner or the professor. You wouldn't expect someone with a peanut allergy to require everyone else to clear any food they bring to class with everyone else beforehand, would you? Similarly, if you had a terrible fear of dissecting frogs, you wouldn't expect your biology professor to clear his/her lesson plans with everyone else beforehand, would you? Absolutely not, if your personal preferences, fears, or allergies conflict with something someone else is legally and rightfully doing in class, it's your own responsibility to raise your concerns and help make accommodation that works for everyone. You have a fear of dogs, but what if instead you had fear of the color red? By the same logic, you would expect anyone wearing the color red to ask the class if they so approved of it. Sound ridiculous? That's because it is. You can't expect others to know your personal fears, preferences, and allergies. You need to take responsibility for yourself, not make other people take responsibility for you.

It sounds like the person and her dog who "never came back again," probably never came back because she decided not to take the course. I highly doubt she was so moved by your change in seat that she decided to give up fostering her dog and saw the "errors in her ways" for bringing it to class. And if you have issues with a dog judging the smell of your clothes, then you have other problems.

JDM
Tue Sep 11 2012 08:30
Are there now assigned seats for lectures ?
Is moving to another seat such an imposition ?
The UofD must follow ADA guidelines for accessabilty to lectures.




log out